22 Launches or 6 to 8? The Starship Moon-Refueling Number Is Back in Dispute

Summary: On NASA's Aerospace Safety Advisory Panel call on Oct. 22, member Charlie Precourt said the latest estimate is "around 22" Starship launches to fuel one lunar landing, and Elon Musk replied that the real number will be "more like 6 to 8." Neither figure has been shown in flight yet, because Starship has not demonstrated ship-to-ship transfer of cryogenic propellant in orbit.

Checked on Oct 23, 2026.

What was said on the call

At the panel's quarterly public meeting, Precourt, a former NASA astronaut, flagged refueling as an Artemis IV risk. "We need to keep our eyes on numerous required fuelings for the lander. I think the last estimate is around 22 flights," he said, as quoted by Ars Technica. Ars's Eric Berger posted the figure on X at 11:43 a.m. Arizona time.

Precourt didn't name Starship. Ars notes that Blue Origin's Blue Moon doesn't use orbital refueling in its initial design, so the figure can only apply to Starship. NASA hasn't published the 22-launch number in a document we could find. It is what was said on the call.

Musk's reply

About 2.5 hours later, Musk replied on X: "That's way too high. Actual number will be more like 6 to 8." That's his projection. SpaceX hasn't published an analysis to back it up.

The number keeps moving

The figure has shifted for years, according to past reporting:

  • 2021: A Government Accountability Office report put the number at 16 launches. Musk said at the time it would be at most eight tanker flights and possibly four, per Ars Technica's 2023 recap.
  • Nov. 2023: NASA's Lakiesha Hawkins said "high teens," while HLS director Lisa Watson-Morgan said "high single digits to the low double digits" (Ars Technica, SpaceNews).
  • Later NASA-SpaceX briefing: SpaceX's Jessica Jensen said "roughly ten-ish" fuel transfers, which could go higher or lower (SpaceNews).

Berger's analysis: even at twice-weekly Starship launches, filling a depot for 22 flights would take about three months (Ars Technica). Musk's 6 to 8 would cut that sharply.

The panel's bigger worry

SpacePolicyOnline reports that the panel plans a formal recommendation that NASA "re-examine the mission objectives, potentially the system architecture for Artemis IV." Precourt pointed to firsts that haven't been tested: an orbital propellant depot, cryogenic transfer in space, and cryogenic propellants used on the lunar surface. He also said NASA requires only one uncrewed landing demo, without a liftoff back to lunar orbit.

The same report says NASA's Kelvin Manning told the Space Studies Board this week that SpaceX plans to demonstrate in-space cryogenic transfer in early 2027, and an uncrewed landing in late 2027.

Where the schedule stands

  • Artemis: Artemis III is targeted for Q3 2027 as a crewed docking test in Earth orbit with no refueling. The crewed landing has moved to Artemis IV, targeted for 2028 (Space.com).
  • Flight 15: NASASpaceFlight reports a no-earlier-than date of Nov. 8, with SpaceX attempting to catch both the booster and the ship (NASASpaceFlight). Musk called success "more likely than not" (Technology.org).
  • First Florida launch: Flight 16 is aimed for December and could be the first Starship launch from Pad 39A, though that depends on how Flight 15 goes (NASASpaceFlight). SpaceX said on Oct. 1 that things are "going super well at 39A" (Space.com).

Louisiana: comment deadline Sunday

Comments are due Oct. 26 in the FAA's request for information on siting new spaceports and launch corridors (Federal Register). The Louisiana Wildlife Federation has filed comments asking the FAA to weigh wetlands, wildlife and coastal hazards as SpaceX pursues its proposed Starbase Louisiana in Vermilion Parish. The group says it isn't opposed to space development. No FAA decision on the site has been announced.

Bottom line

The refueling count largely decides how fast a Moon landing can happen. Until SpaceX flies its first propellant-transfer demo, "22" is the latest estimate cited on a NASA advisory call, and "6 to 8" is Musk's projection.


Enjoyed this? Subscribe to The Weekly Three: https://theweeklythree.beehiiv.com/subscribe

Sources

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

SpaceX's Louisiana Tax Deal Lets It Contest Public Records Before They're Released

Who Gets to See the Terafab Deal? A Citizens Group Takes SpaceX to Court

Tesla Will Wind Down Cybertruck to Make Room for Cybercab, Musk Says